09-16-2018, 04:40 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2018, 04:42 PM by TheOldPresbyope.)
(09-16-2018, 03:41 PM)rongon Wrote: Shuffle-play by Album as opposed to shuffle-play by Track would be especially important for classical music listeners.If you change that to "shuffle-play by work/composition" then would I agree.
...
Some of the works in my classical collection, notably operas, were spread over multiple CDs, some of them were combined on multiple CDs, like Beethoven's 9 symphonies as recorded by a single conductor/orchestra/related-sessions, some were combined on a single CD. Shuffle-play by work would allow me to chew through my collection during casual listening in the way a good classical radio station does. (Candidly, though, I'm usually focused on a specific work or predefined playlist of related works. I let Internet radio and music streaming services fill in my periods of casual listening.)
Some folks would still want shuffle-play by album; think theme albums like "Tommy" by the Who. [edit] I think of this as a work.
Whether shuffling by "album" or by "work" is the choice, the question for me is, what metadata/track naming/file organizational structure would be the primary key? I really don't want to combine multiple tracks into a single file plus cuesheet to get there but I admit I've considered it in the past.
Regards,
Kent