09-14-2022, 02:42 AM
@rongon
Based on decades of reading various forums, it seems pretty obvious to me the easy way to start a e-fight is to argue for a specific tagging scheme for classical works (jazz is a close second). One person's meat is another's poison, to borrow an old phrase
It's a pity the musicologists didn't get this sorted before digital recordings made it possible to include computer-readable metadata as opposed to those nice printed liner notes we used to get.
I took a first look at your files and posted a private reply to you and Tim. I can't examine the tag contents before tomorrow but I've already determined that Mp3tag has done you wrong by sticking ID3 tags on FLAC tracks. The contents may actually be correct but the presence of ID3 tags is incorrect.
Regards,
Kent
Based on decades of reading various forums, it seems pretty obvious to me the easy way to start a e-fight is to argue for a specific tagging scheme for classical works (jazz is a close second). One person's meat is another's poison, to borrow an old phrase
It's a pity the musicologists didn't get this sorted before digital recordings made it possible to include computer-readable metadata as opposed to those nice printed liner notes we used to get.I took a first look at your files and posted a private reply to you and Tim. I can't examine the tag contents before tomorrow but I've already determined that Mp3tag has done you wrong by sticking ID3 tags on FLAC tracks. The contents may actually be correct but the presence of ID3 tags is incorrect.
Regards,
Kent
